 |
| Kaʻū's member of the state House of Representatives Jeanne Kapela held a Keep Kaʻū Country sign on Saturday with other protesters of the proposed Punalu'u development plan that goes to public hearing on May 6. Photo by Ophir Dannenberg |
Mike Tom, long time resident of Punalu'u mauka, also stood in opposition. He said developers lack the understanding and connection to the 'aina there, while locals are raised with respect and appreciation for Punalu'u. He said it is a difference in perspective that prevents the alignment of interests between the residents of Ka'ū and the developers. He emphasized the importance of protecting Punalu'u for generations to come.
The protest was organized by Malama Punalu'u and its leader Guy Enriques who grew up there, with his late mother Janet Howard starting the lei stands at Punalu'u and he and his brothers and sons serving as volunteer lifeguards and protectors of endangered turtles there for many years.
 |
| 'Aina Akamu carries a sign saying Protect Our Sacred Lands. Photo by Ophir Dannenberg |
The hearing is at 9 a.m. at the County Council Chambers in Hilo. It is an extension of a March 7 hearing where time ran out after 88 people testified, with 50 remaining in line. About 80 testified against the proposal and eight for the proposal during the first hearing.The proposal is by Black Sand Beach, LLC. which is asking to place 125 accommodations set back a quarter mile from the shore, along with a wellness center and other commercial enterprise. It also proposes eateries, a market, tour bus drop off and other commercial endeavors near the beach. See more on the proposal from Black Sand Beach, LLC at Punalublacksandbeach.com
See the testimony from the last public hearing on the matter on the County of Hawai'i Planning Department YouTube Channel at https://www.youtube.com/c/CountyofHawaiiPlanningDepartment.
To read comments, add your own, and like this story, see facebook.com/kaucalendar. See upcoming events, print edition and archive at kaunews.com. See 7,500 copies the mail and on stands.
ALIGNMENT OF THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT AT PUNALU'U with the Kaʻū Community Development Plan was a major discussion at the Kaʻū Community Development Plan Action Committee meeting held in Pahala this week.
Committee members and the public quoted from Kaʻū CDP such recommendations as establishing a shoreline setback a quarter of a mile. The proposed development makes that setback for accommodations but not for some of its eateries and other commercial activities near Black Sand Beach.
CDP directives quoted by Action Committee member Babette Morrow included protecting the coast and
minimizing development in the coastal conservation and open areas. She said the CDP recommends: "No development shall be approved in the SMA unless the development would not have any substantial adverse environmental or ecological effect."
Daryn Arai, former Deputy Director of the county Planning Department, who works with the developer, said the project is consistent with the CDP and recommended that the Action Committee give its opinion on the proposal in a statement to the Planning Commission.
Committee members Pernell Hanoa, Kaweni Ibarra, Leina'ala Enos, Jesse Ke, Babette Morrow, Jason Masters and Kaohinani Mokuali'i made up the quorum for the meeting. They concluded that they needed more information on the alignment of the CDP and proposal before deciding whether to make any group statement.
A representative from the County Planning Department noted that Committee members could each submit personal testimony and that the Committee can also decide whether to submit.
During the meeting, Committee Chair Pernell Hanoa stepped down for "personal reasons" and said he would be submitting his own personal testimony on the Punalu'u issue.
Jason Masters was voted to take his place with Hanoa becoming vice chair. Masters emphasized that if the Committee should decide to make a recommendation it should be limited to the development plan's alliance with the CDP.
In public testimony, 'Aina Akamu listed numerous sections in the Kaʻū CDP, stating they show the proposal's non-alignment with the CDP. He pointed to a section stating that economic development should be directed to existing towns in Ka'u and not along the coast. The CDP does recommend building the visitor industry for jobs and entrepreneurship.
ALIGNMENT OF THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT AT PUNALU'U with the Kaʻū Community Development Plan was a major discussion at the Kaʻū Community Development Plan Action Committee meeting held in Pahala this week.
Committee members and the public quoted from Kaʻū CDP such recommendations as establishing a shoreline setback a quarter of a mile. The proposed development makes that setback for accommodations but not for some of its eateries and other commercial activities near Black Sand Beach.
CDP directives quoted by Action Committee member Babette Morrow included protecting the coast and
 |
| Does commercial enterprise near the coast align with the CDP? That was one question discussed at the Action Committee meeting. Photo from Punalu'u Community facebook |
minimizing development in the coastal conservation and open areas. She said the CDP recommends: "No development shall be approved in the SMA unless the development would not have any substantial adverse environmental or ecological effect."
Daryn Arai, former Deputy Director of the county Planning Department, who works with the developer, said the project is consistent with the CDP and recommended that the Action Committee give its opinion on the proposal in a statement to the Planning Commission.
Committee members Pernell Hanoa, Kaweni Ibarra, Leina'ala Enos, Jesse Ke, Babette Morrow, Jason Masters and Kaohinani Mokuali'i made up the quorum for the meeting. They concluded that they needed more information on the alignment of the CDP and proposal before deciding whether to make any group statement.
A representative from the County Planning Department noted that Committee members could each submit personal testimony and that the Committee can also decide whether to submit.
During the meeting, Committee Chair Pernell Hanoa stepped down for "personal reasons" and said he would be submitting his own personal testimony on the Punalu'u issue.
Jason Masters was voted to take his place with Hanoa becoming vice chair. Masters emphasized that if the Committee should decide to make a recommendation it should be limited to the development plan's alliance with the CDP.
In public testimony, 'Aina Akamu listed numerous sections in the Kaʻū CDP, stating they show the proposal's non-alignment with the CDP. He pointed to a section stating that economic development should be directed to existing towns in Ka'u and not along the coast. The CDP does recommend building the visitor industry for jobs and entrepreneurship.
 |
| Ninole would be a preserve and she would be involved in its stewardship, said Sophia Hanoa who supported Black Sand, LLC development plan for Punalu'u during the Community Development Plan Action Committee this week. Photo from Punalu'u Community facebook |
In public testimony, Sophia Hanoa said the folks from Black Sand Beach, LLC are "the first developers who were willing to meet with us." She said she believes they want to protect the coast and solve the sewage treatment problem there. She said they will put Ninole into conservation and that she is involved with its stewardship plan. She said she supports the open market plan near Black Sand Beach.
Candice Ka'awa, who works as land manager for Black Sand Beach, LLC. said she believes in the sincerity of the developers and noted the work done to keep the sewage plant without any spills and the potable water quality high.
Action Committee member Leinaala Enos urged the committee and commission to take more time to "malama" the issue. She said that there are more testimonies coming and more adjustments to be made to the plan. She said that she is a community person and it's "kind of hard to live in Kaʻū and have our people against each other.... We should be more maka'ala and be more attentive." She said if the applicant is willing to again meet with the community, "that is always a positive."
Enos said that the majority of people still need more information. Referring to the small number of people at the meeting and the small groups of people with whom the developers have been recently meeting, Enos said, "It's hard when you have little pockets of people to talk to." She the CDP took eight years to create in the community and contended that any plan for Punalu'u with acceptance by the community could take two, three, five years. "People are saying things and mad with each other. This is not good for our people, not pono."
See the entire Action Committee meeting on the Planning Department's You Tube channel at
https://www.youtube.com/c/CountyofHawaiiPlanningDepartment.
Action Committee member Leinaala Enos urged the committee and commission to take more time to "malama" the issue. She said that there are more testimonies coming and more adjustments to be made to the plan. She said that she is a community person and it's "kind of hard to live in Kaʻū and have our people against each other.... We should be more maka'ala and be more attentive." She said if the applicant is willing to again meet with the community, "that is always a positive."
Enos said that the majority of people still need more information. Referring to the small number of people at the meeting and the small groups of people with whom the developers have been recently meeting, Enos said, "It's hard when you have little pockets of people to talk to." She the CDP took eight years to create in the community and contended that any plan for Punalu'u with acceptance by the community could take two, three, five years. "People are saying things and mad with each other. This is not good for our people, not pono."
See the entire Action Committee meeting on the Planning Department's You Tube channel at
https://www.youtube.com/c/CountyofHawaiiPlanningDepartment.
To read comments, add your own, and like this story, see facebook.com/kaucalendar. See upcoming events, print edition and archive at kaunews.com. See 7,500 copies the mail and on stands.
![]()
.jpg) |
| Community members fill up bags for $10 each at the new thrift store at Naalahu Hongwanji. Photo by Ophir Dannenberg |
 |
| Marcia Masters recently opened a thrift shop at the hongwanji. Photo by Ophir Dannenberg |
A $10 FILL-A BAG SALE drew many to Nāʻālehu Hongwanji lawn on Saturday. It was an event of Nāʻālehu Resilience Hub and its new Under the Bodhi Tree Thrift Shop that opened last month, under the guidance of Marcia Masters. It is open Mondays and Wednesdays from 10:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
Donations of clothes and other items came from Salvation Army in Honoka'a and Doug Arnott in Hilo. The Nāʻālehu Resilience Hub is one of 32 hubs around the island. Its focus is a kitchen that provides free meals. It has been running for four years, with the aim of addressing the issue of food scarcity. The thrift shop opened last month, all profits go toward purchasing food.
The hub also distributes Kaukau for Keiki, organized by Vibrant Hawai'i with food purchased by USDA. It will return once a week from June 16 to July 26 during the summer break when children are out of school and miss out on free school breakfasts and lunches. Information to sign up for Kaukau for Keiki will be made available in late May.
To read comments, add your own, and like this story, see facebook.com/kaucalendar. See upcoming events, print edition and archive at kaunews.com. See 7,500 copies the mail and on stands.
.heic) |
| Trojans beat Honoka'a in five sets of boys volleyball on Saturday. Photo by Ophir Dannenberg |
.heic)